Journal of Spurious Findings · Vol. 1, Issue 292 · ISSN pending (forever) Open access · Not peer reviewed

The Pigeons Know

r ≈ 80% positive

Funeral Expenses Price Index (US) vs NYC "Unsanitary Pigeon Condition" Complaints

As the price of funerals rose, so did complaints about unsanitary pigeons in New York. Statistically, the pigeons are pricing in something.

“Pigeons have always attended funerals uninvited. Now they are simply passing on the cost.”

— Dr. Columba Grey, Office of Avian Economics

Real correlation, fake causation

To turn this r ≈ 80% (positive) relationship between Funeral Expenses Price Index (US) and NYC "Unsanitary Pigeon Condition" Complaints into an actual scientific finding, you would need a plausible mechanism, controlled experiments, and replication across independent datasets. We have none of those. We have a chart that goes up at roughly the same rate twice.

That is the whole game of spurious correlations: the math is fine, the meaning is missing. Two lines can rise together because the population grew, because both phenomena are downstream of the same cultural shift, or because the universe has a sense of humor. Picking the comedic interpretation is the only honest move.

Quote attributed to Dr. Columba Grey, Office of Avian Economics is fictional and intended for entertainment.

This correlation belongs on a wall, a mug, or a t-shirt. Pick your poison:

Share the nonsense

Generate your own

Make your own version of this chart with a fresh AI background and a brand-new terrible joke, or pick any two of 292 datasets. Free, right in your browser.