Journal of Spurious Findings · Vol. 1, Issue 292 · ISSN pending (forever) Open access · Not peer reviewed

The Butter Jingle

r ≈ 79% positive

NYC Ice Cream Truck Noise Complaints vs Butter in US Cold Storage

Every time New Yorkers complain about the ice cream truck's jingle, America's warehouses fill up with more butter. The melody is clearly a dairy supply signal.

“The jingle operates at the exact frequency of a churning drum. Warehouses respond instinctively.”

— Dr. Crème Fraîche, Institute of Dairy Acoustics

Why this correlation is stupid

The numbers above are real. Public data on NYC Ice Cream Truck Noise Complaints and Butter in US Cold Storage happens to move in lockstep closely enough to produce r ≈ 79% (positive) — a value high enough that, in a less skeptical world, someone would file a Substack post about it. Here, it earns a chart and a chuckle.

Statisticians call this a spurious correlation: two trends that share a shape without sharing a cause. With enough variables tracked over enough years, you can find pairings like this one between almost any two phenomena. Confounding factors, common drivers (population growth, smartphone adoption, the unstoppable march of time), or pure chance can all make graphs hold hands.

Source data is drawn from public datasets. We do not endorse any causal claim — only the comedic one.

This correlation belongs on a wall, a mug, or a t-shirt. Pick your poison:

Share the nonsense

Generate your own

Make your own version of this chart with a fresh AI background and a brand-new terrible joke, or pick any two of 292 datasets. Free, right in your browser.